Skip to content
WE’RE ON EBAY LIVE! 🏈 Join our live shows for signed memorabilia & exclusive deals →
WE’RE ON EBAY LIVE! 🏈 Join our live shows →

Authenticated by

JSA Authentication PSA Authentication Beckett Authentication

& Others

Mystery Boxes

<p>Every box contains a genuine autographed piece, certified by JSA, PSA, or Beckett. Choose your sport and price point — from $19.95 entry boxes to Guaranteed Hit tiers with premium signed jerseys and helmets inside.</p>
$99.00
$99.00 - $99.00
$99.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95

Autographed Football Mini Helmet Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Autographed Football Mini Helmet Mystery Box. Current superstars, Hall of Famers and more. Good luck! All Mystery Box Items Come With...

View full details
$99.00
$99.00 - $99.00
$99.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95

Signed Football Jersey Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Autographed Custom Football Jersey Mystery Box featuring current superstars, Hall of Famers, rising stars, and legends from both the N...

View full details
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95

Autographed Basketball Jersey Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Autographed Custom NBA Basketball Jersey Mystery Box. Current superstars, Hall of Famers and more. Get your Basketball Mystery Jersey ...

View full details
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95
$179.00
$179.00 - $179.00
$179.00
$99.95
$99.95 - $99.95
$99.95

Signed Current Football Stars Jersey Mystery Box

Inside each box, you will find one randomly custom autographed and authenticated custom football jersey, signed by a current player. TreVeyon Hende...

View full details
$179.00
$179.00 - $179.00
$179.00
$99.95
$99.95 - $99.95
$99.95
$299.00
$299.00 - $299.00
$299.00
$239.95
$239.95 - $239.95
$239.95

Triple Football Jersey Signed Mystery Box Guaranteed Hit

Score Three Autographed Custom Football Jerseys With One Guaranteed From This List In Every Box - Take A Chance On This Exciting Football Memorabil...

View full details
$299.00
$299.00 - $299.00
$299.00
$239.95
$239.95 - $239.95
$239.95
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95

Autographed Football Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Autographed Football. Current superstars, Hall of Famers, NCAA stars and more. Good luck! All Mystery Box Items Come With A Verified C...

View full details
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95
$249.00
$249.00 - $249.00
$249.00
$199.95
$199.95 - $199.95
$199.95

Signed Football Combo Mystery Box

Unleash the excitement with our Mystery Box, a treasure trove of thrilling surprises! Inside each box awaits an autographed and verified football, ...

View full details
$249.00
$249.00 - $249.00
$249.00
$199.95
$199.95 - $199.95
$199.95
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95

Autographed Baseball Jersey Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Autographed Custom MLB Jersey Mystery Box. Current superstars, Hall of Famers and more. Good luck! All Mystery Box Items Come With A ...

View full details
$89.00
$89.00 - $89.00
$89.00
$59.95
$59.95 - $59.95
$59.95
$119.00
$119.00 - $119.00
$119.00
$79.95
$79.95 - $79.95
$79.95

Autographed Baseball Bat Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Current MLB Superstars, Hall of Famers, All-time Greats And More! All Mystery Box Items Come With A Verified Certificate of Authentici...

View full details
$119.00
$119.00 - $119.00
$119.00
$79.95
$79.95 - $79.95
$79.95
$49.00
$49.00 - $49.00
$49.00
$19.95
$19.95 - $19.95
$19.95

Autographed Overstock Clearance Mystery Box – 8x10 Edition

Unwrap the excitement with the Overstock Clearance Mystery Box – 8x10 Edition! Each box contains a randomly selected autographed 8x10 photo featuri...

View full details
$49.00
$49.00 - $49.00
$49.00
$19.95
$19.95 - $19.95
$19.95
Sold out
$69.95
$69.95 - $69.95
$69.95
$39.95
$39.95 - $39.95
$39.95

Autographed Collector’s Clarence All Sports Mystery Box

Incredible names for just $39! These boxes are packed with our overstock items, including current players on their previous teams. Discover Hall of...

View full details
$69.95
$69.95 - $69.95
$69.95
$39.95
$39.95 - $39.95
$39.95
Sold out
$269.00
$269.00 - $269.00
$269.00
$249.95
$249.95 - $249.95
$249.95

Triple Mini Helmet Autographed Mystery Box Guaranteed Hit

Receive three autographed football mini helmets featuring a guaranteed NFL star from our diverse selection! Each collection is packed with current ...

View full details
$269.00
$269.00 - $269.00
$269.00
$249.95
$249.95 - $249.95
$249.95
$239.95 - $239.95
$239.95
$239.95 - $239.95
$239.95

Full Size Autographed Helmet Mystery Box

1 Random Autographed Full Size Replica Football Helmet Mystery Box Add some excitement to your collection with our Full size Replica Helmet Mystery...

View full details
$239.95 - $239.95
$239.95
$239.95 - $239.95
$239.95
$199.00
$199.00 - $199.00
$199.00
$149.95
$149.95 - $149.95
$149.95

Prime Autographed Football Jersey Mystery box

Inside each box, you will find one randomly autographed and authenticated custom football jersey with a site value of at least $99 and with signifi...

View full details
$199.00
$199.00 - $199.00
$199.00
$149.95
$149.95 - $149.95
$149.95
$69.95 - $69.95
$69.95
$69.95 - $69.95
$69.95

Autographed Baseball Mystery Box

Get 1 Random Autographed signed official major league baseball. Hit tons of current MLB superstars, Hall of Famers & all-time greats And MORE! ...

View full details
$69.95 - $69.95
$69.95
$69.95 - $69.95
$69.95
$99.00 - $99.00
$99.00
$99.00 - $99.00
$99.00

Signed Current Football Stars Mystery Mini Box

Inside Each Box, You Will Find One Randomly Autographed And Authenticated Football Mini Signed By A Current Player. Rj Harvey James Cooks George Ki...

View full details
$99.00 - $99.00
$99.00
$99.00 - $99.00
$99.00
$149.95
$149.95 - $149.95
$149.95
$99.95
$99.95 - $99.95
$99.95

All Sports Slabbed Autographed Card Mystery

Get ready for the ultimate collector’s rush with the Golden Autographs Slabbed Superstars Mystery Box!Each box contains (1) randomly selected slabb...

View full details
$149.95
$149.95 - $149.95
$149.95
$99.95
$99.95 - $99.95
$99.95
$79.95 - $79.95
$79.95
$79.95 - $79.95
$79.95

Autographed Basketball Mystery Box

Get One Random Autographed Basketball Mystery Box Add some excitement to your collection with our Basketball Mystery Box! Each box includes one ran...

View full details
$79.95 - $79.95
$79.95
$79.95 - $79.95
$79.95
$114.99 - $114.99
$114.99
$114.99 - $114.99
$114.99

Shohei Ohtani PSA 10 Graded Los Angeles Dodgers Baseball Card Mystery Pack

You're guaranteed to pull one of the following PSA 10 Shohei Ohtani Los Angeles Dodgers Cards! Complete Hit List: 2024 Topps Chrome L/E ...

View full details
$114.99 - $114.99
$114.99
$114.99 - $114.99
$114.99
$199.00
$199.00 - $199.00
$199.00
$149.95
$149.95 - $149.95
$149.95

Prime Autographed Football Mini Helmet Mystery box

Inside each box, you will find one randomly autographed and authenticated mini football helmet with a site value of at least $99 and with significa...

View full details
$199.00
$199.00 - $199.00
$199.00
$149.95
$149.95 - $149.95
$149.95
$86.25 - $86.25
$86.25
$86.25 - $86.25
$86.25

Signed Basketball Jersey Mystery Box - New York Knicks

Look for Randomly inserted Inscribed Signatures! Please see below for a list of players included in this series:  Amar'e Stoudemire Allan Housto...

View full details
$86.25 - $86.25
$86.25
$86.25 - $86.25
$86.25
$29.95 - $29.95
$29.95
$29.95 - $29.95
$29.95

Certified Autograph Mystery 8x10 – Celebrities, Athletes & Wrestling

Take the mystery and excitement to the next level with our Authenticated Celebrity & Sports Mystery 8x10 Photo! Each order includes ONE (1) ran...

View full details
$29.95 - $29.95
$29.95
$29.95 - $29.95
$29.95
$349.99 - $349.99
$349.99
$349.99 - $349.99
$349.99

Shohei Ohtani PSA 10 Graded Rookie Baseball Card Mystery Pack

You're guaranteed to pull one of the following PSA 10 Shohei Ohtani Rookie Cards! Complete Hit List: 2018 Topps Shohei Ohtani #83-2 1983 PSA 102018...

View full details
$349.99 - $349.99
$349.99
$349.99 - $349.99
$349.99
$98.75 - $98.75
$98.75
$98.75 - $98.75
$98.75

Signed Football Mini Helmet Mystery Box - Dallas Cowboys

Look for Randomly inserted Specialty Mini-Helmets and Inscribed Signatures! Please see below for a list of players included in this series:  Bob L...

View full details
$98.75 - $98.75
$98.75
$98.75 - $98.75
$98.75