Skip to content
Golden Autographs
Golden Autographs
How to Spot Fake Autographed NFL Football Jerseys

How to Spot Fake Autographed NFL Football Jerseys

Identifying fake autographed NFL football jerseys is crucial for collectors and fans alike. Ensuring authenticity not only protects your investment but also maintains the integrity of your collection. Here are some key factors to consider when determining if an autographed jersey is genuine.

1. Certificate of Authenticity (COA)

A Certificate of Authenticity (COA) is a document that guarantees the signature on the jersey is legitimate. Reputable sellers usually provide a COA from a trusted authentication company. Look for COAs from well-known organizations such as PSA/DNA, JSA, or Beckett. Verify the COA's validity by checking the company’s database if available.

2. Holograms and Serial Numbers

Many authentic jerseys come with holograms and serial numbers that are linked to the COA. These holograms are often tamper-proof and include a unique serial number. Check the hologram for signs of tampering, such as peeling or scratches. Ensure the serial number on the hologram matches the one on the COA.

3. Quality of the Autograph

Examine the autograph itself for consistency and quality. Authentic signatures are usually smooth and confident, with no hesitation marks. Compare the autograph to verified examples online. Pay attention to the style, size, and placement of the signature. Fake autographs may appear shaky or inconsistent with known examples.

4. Seller Reputation

Purchase jerseys from reputable sellers who specialize in sports memorabilia. Check for customer reviews, ratings, and any history of complaints. Reputable sellers often provide detailed information about the item’s provenance and authentication process.

5. Price Too Good to Be True

Be wary of deals that seem too good to be true. Authentic autographed jerseys typically have a high value, and prices significantly below market value can be a red flag. Conduct market research to understand the typical price range for similar items.

6. Jersey Quality

Inspect the jersey itself for quality. Authentic jerseys are made from high-quality materials and feature official team logos and patches. Pay attention to stitching, fabric, and overall construction. Poor quality or irregularities can indicate a counterfeit item.

7. Photo or Video Proof

Some authentic autographed jerseys come with photo or video proof of the signing. This evidence shows the player signing the jersey and can add an extra layer of authenticity. While not always available, this documentation is valuable when provided.

8. Third-Party Authentication

Consider using a third-party authentication service if you are unsure about the jersey’s authenticity. These services will examine the autograph and provide an unbiased opinion on its legitimacy. Although this can incur additional costs, it provides peace of mind.


Spotting a fake autographed NFL jersey requires careful examination of several factors, including the COA, holograms, autograph quality, and seller reputation. By following these guidelines, you can significantly reduce the risk of purchasing counterfeit memorabilia. Always stay informed and vigilant to protect your investment in sports collectibles.

About Golden Autographs

Golden Autographs is a legitimate marketplace for sports signed memorabilia, including autographed NFL jerseys by professional players. The platform is dedicated to providing authentic collectibles, ensuring each item comes with a verified Certificate of Authenticity from trusted authentication companies. Golden Autographs is renowned for its extensive collection, excellent customer service, and commitment to authenticity, making it a trusted source for collectors and fans.

Previous article How to Care for Your Signed NFL Jersey Collection
Next article The Perfect Gift for NFL Fans: Signed Jerseys